‘They’re intimidated by the accent’: Readers react to middling ranking of Massachusetts in ‘best state’ poll

We just lately shared a countrywide YouGov survey appearing that Massachusetts ranked because the Thirty first-best state amongst American citizens (not up to each and every different New England state), and we needed to grasp what Boston.com readers considered the… let’s say, uninspiring score.

It gained’t wonder somebody {that a} majority of the over 550 respondents assume the commonwealth must have fared higher: 58 % stated Massachusetts deserved to be upper, together with 9 % who insisted that the state must be No. 1. Many praised the state’s healthcare, its tough economic system, and its extremely skilled populace.

However there have been nonetheless a number of naysayers. One in 4 respondents concept the Bay State were given the score it deserved, whilst 17 % stated it must were even decrease.


A number of criticized the elements, the site visitors, and the prime value of dwelling in Massachusetts, however the greatest offender? The state’s citizens, variously characterised as “boastful,” “unfriendly,” and “looney music lefties.”

As Scott from Cohesion says, “Massachusetts could be glorious if it wasn’t for the individuals who are living there.”

Talking of political animosity: YouGov shared information revealing the partisan affect of American citizens’ critiques on portions of the rustic. As you’re more than likely ready to bet, Democrats overwhelmingly favor liberal states whilst Republicans choose conservative locales.

And the diversities will also be stark. Deep blue California is maximum divisive of all — the rustic’s maximum populous state used to be ranked 2nd amongst Democrats (profitable 79 % of head-to-head matchups, slightly below Hawaii) however lifeless final for Republicans (shedding 76 % of the time).

Massachusetts, any other closely Democratic state, noticed a identical discrepancy. It ranked nineteenth for Democrats, profitable 55 % of matchups, and forty sixth for Republicans, shedding two out of thrice.

However even amongst Democrats, Massachusetts nonetheless ranks not up to each and every different New England state. Every made the highest 15, with Vermont topping the area in ninth. It’s the similar trend for Republicans — whilst Maine controlled to get twenty eighth, the opposite New England states are crowded within the backside 15, with Massachusetts behind the pack.


It kind of feels that regardless of who you ask, Massachusetts is perceived because the stinker of New England, regardless of its dominance within the area.

Neatly, it issues a bit. Over 70 other people left further feedback in our ballot about Massachusetts score Thirty first. Right here’s what a few of them needed to say.

Feedback were edited for period and readability.

We were given hosed, Mass. is No. 1!

“Very best well being care within the nation, a number of jobs, the wonderful thing about Cape Cod and the Berkshires, MIT and Harvard, such a lot historical past, our sports activities groups, main the rustic in AI, biotech and robotics, Boston actions/occasions/exploring town and eating places, scrumptious seafood. I really like Massachusetts!”

“Mass. is a most sensible state because of its very good tutorial establishments, exceptional well being care, management in innovation and introduction of latest companies because of this, historical management in human rights, a inhabitants in a position to essential pondering, and regardless of being a closely Democratic state, steadily electing Republican Governors who’re deemed to be the most productive candidate. Only a few states can declare those attributes.” —Jim from Cohesion

“Mass. laws! Nice economic system, nice faculties (pre-Okay via school), gorgeous coast, historical tradition, liberal attitudes (most commonly), mid-level tax load, low crime, pioneering public healthcare, a state executive that may in truth paintings in combination, welcoming to inexperienced persons — what else do you wish to have? I’ve been all over the place and Massachusetts is the most productive state within the U.S. by way of a mile.” —Invoice from Northborough

“I’ve lived a number of puts, and Massachusetts is by way of a long way the most productive. I really like how persons are forthright, and inform it adore it is. We now have the most productive schooling on the earth. I feel other people in crimson states view us as the top of the “radical left” and demonize us because of this. I feel the truth that many of us come right here for varsity and not depart speaks for itself.”

Mass. isn’t No. 1, however it merits higher


“Massachusetts has all of it — seashores, mountains, cultural reports statewide, 4 gorgeous seasons, historical past… the listing is going on and on. I’ve finished an even quantity of home and world shuttle and I’m all the time thankful of what I’ve so shut at house.” —Tina from Boston

“Even if we is also temporarily written off as a sports activities hub with a host of loopy drivers, there’s a lot to realize right here. We now have world-class hospitals, an abundance of spectacular faculties and universities, process alternatives, a number of waterfront communities, eateries, and scrumptious seafood. The negatives? Surely from time to time the folk and tempo of lifestyles… Jap Mass. and town is busy and congested, so other folks are most commonly irritable or in a hurry. Value of housing is insanely prime and that’s any other problem. Different American citizens more than likely hate the Bostonian angle and cockiness. General, Massachusetts has some attraction and a few crap, however doesn’t each and every state?” —Jocelyn from Peabody

“Mass. rankings very low in climate, site visitors, affordability, and normal friendliness of the inhabitants. That’s kinda laborious to conquer. It rankings upper in city attractiveness (Boston is likely one of the prettiest towns within the nation), arts and delicacies, professional sports activities, occupation alternatives, crime, and seashores. It must be in the course of the pack someplace.”

“Massachusetts is pricey for a reason why: It’s wealthy with alternative, offering a various, dynamic economic system, very good faculties in any respect ranges, and is inside an afternoon’s power of many gorgeous out of doors sights. Many of us from different states don’t notice simply how just right the standard of day-to-day lifestyles is right here.” —Doug from Hopkinton

“I feel Massachusetts is underrated by way of individuals who have by no means visited. It has numerous great structure, old-world vibes, and beautiful cities. After which in an financial sense, we indubitably have much more jobs and higher get entry to to schooling and healthcare. I additionally sincerely imagine Massachusetts is house to a big proportion of in reality clever other people, however will that make other people wish to rank us upper at the listing? Almost certainly no longer.”

“It’s the abruptness of Massachusetts citizens, the coarse ‘Masshole’ angle, particularly to strangers. It’s an overly dependable bunch if you get previous this, however utterly off-putting to these no longer used to it. Maine citizens are such a lot hotter, laid again, pleasant and inviting all over the place you move.” —Sue from Scituate

“Maine is so a lot more laid again and no longer as boastful or self-centered as our neighbors to the south—they’re no longer referred to as Massholes for no reason why. However Mass. is a brilliant state with nice sports activities groups, and Boston is this kind of taking place town. It’s no longer #1 and it’s no longer higher than Maine, however it’s indubitably higher than Rhode Island and Connecticut.” —Mike from Scarborough, Maine

“They’re intimidated by way of the accessory and the Southie difficult man mythology from the films.” —Danny from Charlestown

Mass. isn’t that fab, Thirty first sounds proper

“Persons are egocentric and impolite. Massachusetts is terribly racist for a northern state. Taxes and price of dwelling are too prime. Wages are too prime. Roads and site visitors are terrible. Nice healthcare and lots of out of doors actions are the nice portions. There’s extra dangerous issues about Mass than just right. I feel it’s proper the place it belongs at the listing.”

“The score is most probably skewed by way of the specific people who occur to take part within the survey, Alternatively, the belief of Massachusetts as a ‘nanny state’ is correct for the ones located heart/proper politically, from gun regulations to forcing regulations. Because the pronouncing is going, ‘belief is truth’ without reference to how correct that truth is.” —Sean from Westport

“It’s simply no longer a pleasant, welcoming position. I do know it is a level of satisfaction for Massachusetts citizens however it doesn’t grasp throughout the remainder of the rustic.” —’A’ from Cambridge

Mass. must be decrease!

“Massachusetts has too many boastful other folks, too many uptight other folks, and too many laws/regulations/statutes. Additionally, in some portions, it simply has too many of us, packed approach too intently in combination.” —Bob from Rockport, Maine

“Mass. is stuffed with stuck-up individuals who know higher than you, and gained’t help you put out of your mind about it. Mix that with a relative loss of herbal attractiveness, and ridiculously prime taxes and I’m surprised we didn’t rank decrease.” —Conor from Boston

“No edginess. Too vanilla. Meals scene: no longer inventive. Blue regulations like no ingesting outdoor with out ordering meals, no dancing, gaming, and so on. and not using a license = regulations towards grownup amusing = depressing state. Omit historical past, focal point at the long run, Massachusetts.” —Jack from Massachusetts

“The price of dwelling throughout the 495 loop is solely totally ridiculous, we must be ranked within the backside 5 because of value of dwelling by myself.”

“As somebody no longer initially from right here, Mass. citizens born listed below are indignant, imply, and unwelcoming other people. By no means a wave at the approach out of the community, and dressed in a ‘Mass****’ moniker as a praise proves my level. Additionally, discover ways to power.”

“The individuals who are living right here, local or carpetbagger, are overwhelmingly boastful, illiberal of the ones they disagree with, impolite, and unfriendly. They continuously elect witless fools after which post with the amazingly inefficient, dear, and incompetent executive that comes of it. However they congratulate themselves always about how nice they’re. Somewhat humility could be warranted.”

Boston.com once in a while interacts with readers by way of accomplishing casual polls and surveys. Those effects must be learn as an unscientific gauge of readers’ critiques.

Get Boston.com’s browser signals:

Permit breaking information notifications immediately on your web browser.

Activate notifications

Nice, you’re signed up!

Related Post